Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Which Ac Is Best Onida,voltas,hitachi

What legitimacy to exist for ENS? (3) What

The wage issue normaliens.

The rationale for the salary paid to the ENS has therefore just what they are supposed to be the best: the Republic finance the studies of his best students, and part-cons, they agree to work ten years for her. Normal.

The egalitarian (and I call those who, rightly, would like all French students are treated the same criteria) would agree that if any one was absolutely sure that ENS are the best French students.

We have seen that this is not necessarily the case. First, although we are generally among the best, we are not absolutely the best and not have built does not, fortunately we can not take part. Then there are always people who either never hear about ENS and prepared or do not support it and leave even before the real fun begin: I came second to the first level control Latin, Hypokhâgne: the first was not even there to retrieve his copy: it was gone after one week.

This raises the question of informing pupils and students on the existence of PERs and the ENS and, therefore, the ambition we have for them: do not be silent because that it is estimated they will not succeed, but talk to them and let them make their own choices, while being clear on their level, if not, either, seeing them engage in a siding.


Finally, is it a problem not to ENS?

can also wonder if it really is a problem not to be passed by ENS. If you want to do research, it is undoubtedly harder: One can say many things at the school, but we can not deny the huge "boost" that represent a catalyst, its status Great School and its reputation, the scholarships it distributes and the facilities it offers to entertain people and make themselves known to them (it is easier to dare contact a U.S. researcher intervene when we see regularly in his department). Of course this does not mean there is no good research out of the ENS, fortunately.

There is no denying, either, that his preparations various aggregations are either the best or among the best.

But in other cases, it is not fenced sure we need to attempt to integrate, even to a class Preparatory.

This means that the system does not fund the ENS a part of university courses (in addition to not fund a portion of their students) and must therefore also that the best students from other disciplines can also be delivered by the state. It is quite correct that there are scholarships based on income, it seems it is also necessary that there be at hand, merit scholarships, based on the results (with still some consideration of income: it is not just a student, even excellent, super financed by income parents off, receive a scholarship "pocket money").



moral problem associated

It is indeed quite unbearable to consider that the university would be "reserved" to "bad". I will not dwell on the fact that it is not true of students, it seems to have already developed. So I would add "only" this is not the case for teachers: as students, some of the teachers is composed of former ENS, others to be where they are, have distinguished themselves also, for their excellence: let's be clear, even if everyone has an example in mind, myself included, rarely become ill college professor.

After, this does not mean that 'they will be excellent teachers: the meaning of pedagogy, it was or not, we can learn it in part but love teaching, it is basically a matter of taste. It is not always easy to end up before a room full of students, preparing lessons is time consuming and sometimes rather desperate need to correct some forty comments corrected in two weeks requires a good dose of self-motivation ("I the sacred fire, the fire I, I ...").

That said, I find it quite normal and even necessary, the dual role of teacher-researcher. The university is a place of transmission between research and made to inform students of its past advanced. The university is also a place thought: there are many ideas on his own field of research even prepared lessons that are quite far away (after I pulled the hair on my course in French literature nineteenth and twentieth centuries, I then realized that it put me in contact with a number of concepts that can absolutely be part of my thesis project). Finally, the university is a place of exchange : while the teacher delivers instruction, but students are (usually) not passive either; also have ideas and, above all, see things with fresh eyes.

In short and to return to the subject, the university is far from the hideout of the "bad", whether teachers or students, and should, also, to fund his best students.


(Concluded next time)

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Giant Cupcake Silicone Mould

legitimacy to exist for ENS? (2) What

The issue of training.

Normal To enter, you must be a preparatory class, which means that the ENS does not pass through the first two years of college. That said, this does not mean that the ENS does not go through college at all : School does not award diplomas, which means that we must at least be enrolled in a university (for scientists) and also to monitor the progress (for literature). It is therefore wrong to say that we are totally alien to the university: it is in his background that we make our two-year Master (+ sometimes the last license year) and our thesis that there is Professor who heads our research, we work here after school. We are part of the university, the difference with other students is that we also follow other courses elsewhere, which, in the third year degree, results in an insane schedule, even by removing the current "double".

Here we are confronted with different levels with students who have done that in college . This is not true in all subjects, but to give you an idea, L3 classics, I found myself with people who were still in the BA-BA in Greek, or who were totally unable to translate a basic text in this language - as they were trying to finish their license: it was therefore at least the third year they were Greek. You will understand why I deserted to follow the course equivalent in Ulm: I honestly feel that wasting my time, or even worse, losing my level (which was not quite true, because the versions were when even corrected fairly "dry").

As a first very basic, ie, leaving for the moment, ENS outside the table, this raises the question of the level required for college from one year to another, arriving third-year classics without knowing even the most elementary rules of Greek grammar seems totally unacceptable, both for the university and said die, more importantly, for students, which was allowed to go straight into the wall honking.

"Yes, but you might say, given the few students in classics, if they are being fired because they did not level it will really end up with three peeled and shaved ! The problem of classical literature is another matter, he would undoubtedly good deal here too long: all I will say for now is that it seems to me that allowing a student who has very clearly not continue through the level third year is totally unacceptable.

So two things: either one considers that the problem is him and he says he is not in its interest to continue in this way (after all, the advantage of college is that there are many opportunities for diversion), or we consider that the problem is we are reviewing our requirements and meet our students and the education we deliver them (you saw? think I already as teacher is wonderful).

However, even in sectors where the level of requirement is really ok, the ENS and former préparationnaires (because, compared to students who have made the college, ex-préparationnaires must also come into account - it's not just the ENS, in life!) proved best and frankly what they are mostly found in the aggregation and received the best ranks among the Caps received (which does not mean that others have no chance to be as well, fortunately).

From my point of view, it is a question of method: the training received in prep school is very focused on the methodology, with exercises and frequent. They may say there is nothing more effective to integrate the rules of the essay and the text commentary (I Leaving aside the intrinsic necessity of becoming more or less a workhorse dubbed a genius for organization, makes you laugh gently when you give then a month to make a point). In college, the exercises are fewer (to give you an idea, my students need me a comment made at the end of the month in preparation, I'd already made two and the third is on the way) and the methodology clearly less hammered, judging, after the difficulties experienced by students to organize their work.

What college is less "psycho" as the preparation no problem: after all, why not? Nobody is obliged to follow the paths canonically formatted to think for yourself and do something good (it is one of the advantages of prépas provincial over prépas Paris: think different, guys!). Nevertheless, we must still be built a certain way to get there and what is often lacking in students (for reasons of convenience, I call now "students" who have studied that in college, he should not however forget that ex-préparationnaires and ENS are also of students): they are not as good in themselves, they often struggle to organize their thinking to make it go further.

can now wonder if they would be better if they knew it. In my opinion, yes: the good and even better would have the same weapons as the others, the poor are the least ill have other problems (or the same, but at least in terms of organize their thoughts, they would know how they should ideally be). You might say: "Yes, but the best are not in college, they are in prep school!". This is probably partly true, but what I know, myself, is that the freshmen that I have before me right now are just as good as Hypokhâgne and they are not prepared, meaning that the university has immense potential and affirm that only one is going bad absolutely false.

Another problem: think different is good, but if you want to spend the contest or other education is mainly on your ability to conform to a mold that will judge you ( not only do something original leads necessarily a failure, but let's be clear: the aggregation, it is not at all what is expected of you). Gold this mold is education as it is issued in prep school, it is considered good or not, this raises problems for students, starting with a handicap.

It is therefore understandable that the former ENS and préparationnaires students do better than "short" since they have integrated a moment on what we know was going to try and comply. After that the ENS often prove better than the former préparationnaires (but not all the time and, above all, not necessarily: to integrate, it must be good enough everywhere, which means that if you are good in Latin, but no one in history and philosophy, you will not integrate, but if you continue to study Latin literature, there are good chances that you're as good as people who have built: so do no complex) is explained easily enough: the fact that they have already integrated means that at one point they were better than them, and then the level of the courses at the ENS remains high and the preparation is good, they enjoy other advantages. I might also add that there are people who are "facts" for the contest (there are even nutcases who can not live if they have no competition to pass) and people who are not made for that. A friend of mine was told that the aggregation was like a marriage: that it works, it takes two, it's a little idea.

Now this question of being better than others is crucial, because this is what justifies and légimitise the salary they pay us.

To be continued ...

(I'm sorry, but all this took me even longer than expected, I'm afraid I can not continue when pensions Italy, ie from next Monday .. .)

Tuesday, November 9, 2010

Customize Sports Pinnies

legitimacy to exist for ENS? (1)

I made a lengthy and reasoned response to a comment obviously very upset against "pampering" normaliens , but I think it deserves a longer development than 4000 characters, even splitting into two parts. The issue seems to me entirely fair: what is the legitimacy of the ENS to exist?

Subject-river, which will take several posts, so as not to impose a lengthy development: not excellent Master Eolas wants. I publish therefore first today, then the other two with an interval of two days each time, not that I'm trying to "subtly" spread the messages to support the attendance of this blog, but simply that I'm leaving tomorrow Italy for a little less than a week and I can not immediately respond to comments.

But, since each message will have a thematic unit (now a little history and then Relations between the ENS and the University and finally a larger question about the university and the French school system - yes, I know, I do not fly the elbow !), You will not have to wait for the reasoning for comment.

Once back, I'll put links between messages, the way of what I did for my translation of an article by AJ Woodman .

Here lets go.


Blame the Ecole Normale Superieure

often blamed for the Grandes Ecoles to form parallel university systems that have therefore relatively little reason to be, since there are already in college and could or should be quite sufficient. In an egalitarian vision (which, I must admit, I like a lot) where everyone would go through college and would be proven, they appear in fact as a symbol of insufferable elitism, which does not deign s lowering up study on the same benches as "populist" (one of the few expressions trigger in me a tremendous desire to hit the person who comes to pronounce it). This is the famous "school which says normal and feels superior" Paul Nizan (oh no! Not Sartre!), Himself Normale elsewhere.

Let's start with a brief history on why it was created.


the beginning was the teacher of teachers.

Initially, the ENS has been created to train teachers who would form ... teachers.

Let me explain: before, to be a teacher at all, you spend the assistance of the Normal School of Teachers (which later became the IUFM and now that it's supposed to have disappeared, I do not know what it's called), if you were accepted, it was a sacred social promotion for students in good working and middle classes in school, even over the certificate of studies.

But the question arose of who was going to train these future Instits? He was Teacher of teachers, so we created the Ecole Normale Superior (who was so superior because it was located above the Normal School for short). Of course, this summary is very fast: in the corner where a historian who wants to make a more detailed discussion, it is welcome.

was entered on the school competition, which, I repeat, is, whatever one thinks of the Republican principle of meritocracy: it is the best at the end of the ordeal that integrate and not those relationships (as might be the case with a recruitment desk: you take the boys, the son of ..., etc.).. Whether you are the son of working-class or aristocratic, if you're good, you have the same opportunities to enter than any other candidate, no more, no less (do not start screaming, we're here in the theory ; we will then discuss the veracity of this principle in practice).

Once you had entered, the state considered (and still believes) that you represent the elite of the school system and, therefore, you pay in exchange for a pledge to pay back for ten years, working for it or by refunding all monies collected (that is what I presented here ).


Later developments.

Then what happened is that the "Teacher Teacher" being increasingly driven to officiate at the university, especially as there were the teachers of middle and high school to form, the number of ENS were divided between those destined to secondary education and those who decided to do research and teach in college. Needless to deny: today, most of us choose the university and is a teaching to do research that we issued. Suddenly, the SLA began to truly represent a "competitor" of the university to train members of the elite Republican in general, and future researchers in particular.